Best Insurance Companies for Drivers With Points — Indiana
Free to compare
Why Standard Carriers Drop You Before Suspension
You received a speeding ticket for 15 over (4 points under Indiana Code 9-24-2), paid the fine, and assumed the matter was closed. Three months later your carrier sends a non-renewal notice even though you're still 16 points away from the BMV's 20-point suspension threshold. The carrier isn't waiting for the state to act — their underwriting guidelines trigger a tier change or declination at 6 to 8 points, not 20.
Indiana's point system operates on two parallel tracks. The BMV counts points to determine license suspension eligibility under IC 9-30-10-16. Carriers count the same points to determine underwriting tier and pricing. A driver with 8 points faces zero state action but immediate carrier action. Most suspended-license scenarios start here: you lose coverage long before you lose your license, and if you drive uninsured waiting for a new quote, the BMV suspends you for that instead.
“Standard carriers reprice points more punitively than non-standard carriers price them initially.”
Get Insured and Get Your Indiana License Back
Get My Indiana Suspended License Insurance Quote6–8 points
Carrier Tier-Change Threshold
Standard carriers in Indiana typically move drivers to non-standard tiers or decline renewal when point totals reach 6 to 8 within a 3-year lookback period. This threshold is significantly lower than the state's 20-point suspension trigger and explains why drivers lose coverage before receiving any BMV suspension notice.
Carrier underwriting guidelines, Indiana market
Which Carriers Write Point-Tier Coverage in Indiana
Four carriers dominate Indiana's point-tier market: Dairyland, Bristol West, GAINSCO, and The General. All four write non-standard auto, accept drivers with points, and file SR-22 when required. They differ significantly in monthly premium structure and point tolerance.
Dairyland and Bristol West accept drivers with up to 12 points if the violations are spaced across three years and no single incident involved DUI or reckless driving. GAINSCO accepts point totals up to 10 but prices more aggressively for drivers under 25. The General accepts higher point counts (up to 15 in some cases) but requires larger down payments and shorter payment plans. Progressive and Geico write some point-tier business in Indiana but typically cap eligibility at 6 points — above that threshold they refer applicants to non-standard subsidiaries.
None of these carriers advertise point thresholds publicly. You discover eligibility only by quoting. A declination from one does not predict declination from another because each carrier's appetite varies by violation type, recency, age, and whether you bundle other policies. Drivers with 10 points from speeding violations often secure coverage more easily than drivers with 6 points including one reckless driving charge.
The critical distinction: non-standard carriers do not penalize point accumulation as harshly as standard carriers re-pricing existing policies. A driver paying $180/month with State Farm at zero points might see renewal quotes of $420/month after acquiring 8 points. That same driver quoting Dairyland or Bristol West fresh faces $240–$310/month — higher than the original premium but significantly lower than the re-priced standard tier.
Standard carriers reprice points more punitively than non-standard carriers price them initially. Switching to a point-specialist carrier often costs less than staying with your current insurer.
Related Articles
How Long Points Affect Your Premium
Indiana assigns points at conviction, not citation. The speeding ticket you received in March 2024 carries zero points until you pay the fine or a court enters judgment — that payment or judgment date starts the clock. Points remain on your BMV record for two years from conviction date under IC 9-24-3-4, but carriers assess points on a three-year lookback for underwriting purposes.
A conviction from April 2023 drops off your BMV record in April 2025 but continues influencing your premium through April 2026. This one-year gap explains why drivers see rate reductions lag behind point expiration. Switching carriers immediately after points expire can bypass the lag — the new carrier pulls your current BMV record, sees zero active points, and quotes accordingly. Your existing carrier relies on their internal record and may not re-rate until your next renewal cycle.
Drivers who complete a BMV-approved defensive driving course can remove up to 4 points from their record once every three years under IC 9-30-9-4. The course costs approximately $65 to $95, takes 4 to 6 hours, and must be Indiana-certified. Completing the course before quoting new coverage removes those points from the carrier's underwriting calculation immediately. Completing it after securing coverage triggers a re-rating at your next renewal but does not reduce your current premium mid-term unless you request a manual re-quote from your carrier.
3 years
Carrier Point Lookback Period
Indiana carriers assess points on a three-year lookback for underwriting and pricing purposes, one year longer than the BMV's two-year active point window under IC 9-24-3-4. A conviction that no longer threatens suspension can still inflate your premium until it ages past the carrier's lookback threshold.
IC 9-24-3-4; carrier underwriting practices
When SR-22 Filing Becomes Required
Points alone do not trigger SR-22 requirements in Indiana. The BMV requires SR-22 filing only after specific triggering events: DUI/OWI conviction under IC 9-30-5, accumulating 20 points within 24 months and reaching suspension under IC 9-30-10-16, driving uninsured and causing an accident, or habitual traffic violator designation under IC 9-30-10-4. A driver with 12 points from speeding violations who has never been suspended does not need SR-22.
If your point total reaches 20 within 24 months, the BMV suspends your license and requires SR-22 as a condition of reinstatement. The filing period is typically three years from reinstatement date. SR-22 is proof of insurance, not a separate policy — your carrier files Form SR-22 electronically with the BMV on your behalf. Dairyland, Bristol West, GAINSCO, The General, Geico, Progressive, and State Farm all file SR-22 in Indiana. Filing fees range from $15 to $50 depending on carrier; the fee is separate from your premium.
Compare Coverage Before Your Next Violation
The fourth speeding ticket is the one that suspends you. Indiana's 20-point threshold sounds distant until you map the math: one reckless driving charge (6 points) plus three speeding violations at 15+ over (4 points each) totals 18 points. One more moving violation of any kind triggers suspension, SR-22 requirements, a $250 reinstatement fee under IC 9-29-8, and premiums that double again on top of your already-elevated point-tier rate. Securing coverage now — while you are still 8 to 12 points below suspension — costs significantly less than waiting until the BMV acts.
Quote all four point-specialist carriers listed above. Provide identical coverage selections to each so premium comparisons reflect underwriting differences, not coverage differences. If one carrier declines you, quote the others anyway — declination from GAINSCO does not predict declination from Dairyland. Compare the monthly cost of liability-only coverage against full coverage if your vehicle is financed; lenders require comprehensive and collision, and dropping it to save money triggers a lender-placed policy that costs more and provides less protection. Start the comparison process now, before your next renewal notice arrives with a non-renewal decision already made.
Monthly Premium Ranges by Point Count
Drivers with 6 to 8 points typically pay $195 to $285/month with Dairyland or Bristol West, $210 to $295/month with GAINSCO, and $225 to $310/month with The General. At 10 to 12 points, premiums rise to $260–$340/month (Dairyland/Bristol West), $285–$365/month (GAINSCO), and $295–$380/month (The General). Point count alone does not determine final premium — a driver with 10 points from three speeding tickets spaced two years apart prices lower than a driver with 8 points including one failure-to-yield causing an accident.
Drivers under 25 or over 65 face surcharges of 15% to 35% on top of base point-tier pricing. Adding comprehensive and collision coverage to a point-tier policy doubles the monthly cost in most cases, though carriers sometimes waive collision on vehicles older than 10 years. Full coverage for a driver with 10 points typically runs $520–$680/month depending on vehicle value and deductible structure. Estimates are based on available market data; individual quotes vary by ZIP code, claims history, credit tier, and bundling discounts.
Get Your Free Quote
Get My Indiana Suspended License Insurance QuoteFrequently Asked Questions
How many points does it take to lose your license in Indiana?
Indiana suspends your license when you accumulate 20 points within any 24-month period under IC 9-30-10-16. Points are assigned at conviction, not citation. A speeding ticket 15 mph over the limit carries 4 points; reckless driving carries 6 points. The BMV sends a suspension notice when your total reaches 20, and reinstatement requires a $250 fee plus SR-22 filing for three years.
Can I get car insurance with 10 points on my license in Indiana?
Yes. Dairyland, Bristol West, GAINSCO, and The General all write coverage for Indiana drivers with 10 points. Monthly premiums for liability-only coverage typically range from $260 to $365 depending on violation type, recency, age, and ZIP code. Standard carriers like State Farm or Allstate usually decline or non-renew drivers above 6 to 8 points, but non-standard carriers specialize in point-tier business.
Do insurance companies see points that the BMV removed?
No, but there's a timing gap. Indiana removes points from your BMV record two years after conviction under IC 9-24-3-4. Carriers use a three-year lookback for underwriting. A conviction from 2022 drops off your BMV record in 2024 but can still affect your premium through 2025 if your current carrier hasn't re-rated you. Switching carriers after points expire forces a fresh underwriting pull and eliminates the lag.
Does a defensive driving course reduce points in Indiana?
Yes. Indiana allows you to remove up to 4 points from your record by completing a BMV-approved defensive driving course under IC 9-30-9-4. You can use this option once every three years. The course costs $65 to $95 and takes 4 to 6 hours. Completing it before quoting new coverage removes those points from the carrier's calculation immediately; completing it after securing coverage triggers a rate reduction at your next renewal.
Will my premium go down automatically when my points expire?
Not always. Points drop off your BMV record two years after conviction, but your current carrier may not re-rate your policy until the next renewal cycle. Some carriers continue pricing based on their internal record even after the BMV clears the points. Requesting a manual re-quote or switching to a new carrier after points expire forces the carrier to pull your current BMV record and quote accordingly, often producing immediate savings.
Do I need SR-22 if I have points but no suspension?
No. Points alone do not trigger SR-22 requirements in Indiana. The BMV requires SR-22 only after specific events: DUI/OWI conviction, license suspension for accumulating 20 points, driving uninsured and causing an accident, or habitual traffic violator designation. A driver with 12 points who has never been suspended does not need SR-22 unless one of these triggers applies.